ode_solver_factory.cpp

#include "ode_solver_factory.h"
#include "parameters/all_parameters.h"
#include "ode_solver_base.h"
#include "runge_kutta_ode_solver.h"
#include "low_storage_runge_kutta_ode_solver.h"
#include "implicit_ode_solver.h"
#include "relaxation_runge_kutta/algebraic_rrk_ode_solver.h"
#include "relaxation_runge_kutta/root_finding_rrk_ode_solver.h"
#include "pod_galerkin_ode_solver.h"
#include "pod_petrov_galerkin_ode_solver.h"
#include "pod_galerkin_runge_kutta_ode_solver.h"
#include "hyper_reduced_petrov_galerkin_ode_solver.h"
#include <deal.II/distributed/solution_transfer.h>
#include "runge_kutta_methods/runge_kutta_methods.h"
#include "runge_kutta_methods/low_storage_runge_kutta_methods.h"
#include "relaxation_runge_kutta/empty_RRK_base.h"

namespace PHiLiP {
namespace ODE {

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_ODESolver(std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    pcout << "Creating ODE Solver..." << std::endl;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    const ODEEnum ode_solver_type = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.ode_solver_type;
    if((ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::runge_kutta_solver)||(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::rrk_explicit_solver || ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::low_storage_runge_kutta_solver))     
        return create_RungeKuttaODESolver(dg_input); 
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::implicit_solver)         
        return std::make_shared<ImplicitODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input);
    else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, false);
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_ODESolver(std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input, std::shared_ptr<ProperOrthogonalDecomposition::PODBase<dim>> pod)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    pcout << "Creating ODE Solver..." << std::endl;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    const ODEEnum ode_solver_type = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.ode_solver_type;
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_galerkin_solver)
        return std::make_shared<PODGalerkinODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input, pod);
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_petrov_galerkin_solver) 
        return std::make_shared<PODPetrovGalerkinODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input, pod);
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_galerkin_runge_kutta_solver)
        return create_RungeKuttaODESolver(dg_input, pod);
    else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, true);
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_ODESolver(std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input, std::shared_ptr<ProperOrthogonalDecomposition::PODBase<dim>> pod, Epetra_Vector weights)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    pcout << "Creating ODE Solver..." << std::endl;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    const ODEEnum ode_solver_type = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.ode_solver_type;
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::hyper_reduced_petrov_galerkin_solver) 
        return std::make_shared<HyperReducedODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input, pod, weights);
    else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, true);
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_ODESolver_manual(Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum ode_solver_type, std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    pcout << "Creating ODE Solver..." << std::endl;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    if((ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::runge_kutta_solver)||(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::rrk_explicit_solver))     
        return create_RungeKuttaODESolver(dg_input);
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::implicit_solver)         
        return std::make_shared<ImplicitODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input);
    else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, false);
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_ODESolver_manual(Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum ode_solver_type, std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input, std::shared_ptr<ProperOrthogonalDecomposition::PODBase<dim>> pod)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    pcout << "Creating ODE Solver..." << std::endl;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_galerkin_solver) 
        return std::make_shared<PODGalerkinODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input, pod);
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_petrov_galerkin_solver) 
        return std::make_shared<PODPetrovGalerkinODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input, pod);
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_galerkin_runge_kutta_solver)
        return create_RungeKuttaODESolver(dg_input, pod);
    else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, true);
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_ODESolver_manual(Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum ode_solver_type, std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input, std::shared_ptr<ProperOrthogonalDecomposition::PODBase<dim>> pod, Epetra_Vector weights)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    pcout << "Creating ODE Solver..." << std::endl;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    if(ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::hyper_reduced_petrov_galerkin_solver) 
        return std::make_shared<HyperReducedODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(dg_input, pod, weights);
    else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, true);
        return nullptr;
    }
}


template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
void ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::display_error_ode_solver_factory(Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum ode_solver_type, bool reduced_order) 
{
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;

    std::string solver_string;    
    if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::runge_kutta_solver)                 solver_string = "runge_kutta";
    else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::implicit_solver)               solver_string = "implicit";
    else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::rrk_explicit_solver)           solver_string = "rrk_explicit";
    else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_galerkin_solver)           solver_string = "pod_galerkin";
    else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_petrov_galerkin_solver)    solver_string = "pod_petrov_galerkin";
    else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::hyper_reduced_petrov_galerkin_solver)    
                                                                        solver_string = "hyper_reduced_petrov_galerkin";
    else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::low_storage_runge_kutta_solver)    
                                                                        solver_string = "low_storage_runge_kutta_solver";
    else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_galerkin_runge_kutta_solver)
                                                                        solver_string = "pod_galerkin_runge_kutta";
    else solver_string = "undefined";
    

    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    pcout << "********************************************************************" << std::endl;
    pcout << "Can't create ODE solver since solver type is not clear." << std::endl;
    pcout << "Solver type specified: " << solver_string << std::endl;
    pcout << "Solver type possible: " << std::endl;
    if(reduced_order){
        pcout <<  "pod_galerkin" << std::endl;
        pcout <<  "pod_petrov_galerkin" << std::endl;
        pcout <<  "pod_galerkin_runge_kutta" << std::endl;
    }
    else{
        pcout <<  "runge_kutta" << std::endl;
        pcout <<  "implicit" << std::endl;
        pcout <<  "rrk_explicit" << std::endl;
        pcout << "    With rrk_explicit only being valid for " <<std::endl;
        pcout << "    pde_type = burgers, flux_nodes_type = GLL, overintegration = 0, and dim = 1" <<std::endl;
    }
    pcout << "********************************************************************" << std::endl;
    std::abort();
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_RungeKuttaODESolver(std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    std::shared_ptr<RKTableauBase<dim,real,MeshType>> rk_tableau = create_RKTableau(dg_input);
    std::shared_ptr<EmptyRRKBase<dim,real,MeshType>> RRK_object = create_RRKObject(dg_input, rk_tableau);


    const int n_rk_stages = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.n_rk_stages;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    const ODEEnum ode_solver_type = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.ode_solver_type;
    if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::runge_kutta_solver || ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::rrk_explicit_solver) {

        // Type-cast to the appropriate RKTableau type
        std::shared_ptr<RKTableauButcherBase<dim,real,MeshType>> rk_tableau_butcher = std::dynamic_pointer_cast<RKTableauButcherBase<dim,real,MeshType>>(rk_tableau); 
        // Hard-coded templating of n_rk_stages because it is not known at compile time
        pcout << "Creating Runge Kutta ODE Solver with " 
              << n_rk_stages << " stage(s)..." << std::endl;
        if (n_rk_stages == 1){
            return std::make_shared<RungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,1,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 2){
            return std::make_shared<RungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,2,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 3){
            return std::make_shared<RungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,3,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 4){
            return std::make_shared<RungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,4,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object);
        }
        else{
            pcout << "Error: invalid number of stages. Aborting..." << std::endl;
            std::abort();
            return nullptr;
        }
    } else if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::low_storage_runge_kutta_solver) {
        std::shared_ptr<LowStorageRKTableauBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ls_rk_tableau = std::dynamic_pointer_cast<LowStorageRKTableauBase<dim,real,MeshType>>(rk_tableau); 

        // Hard-coded templating of n_rk_stages because it is not known at compile time
        pcout << "Creating Low-Storage Runge Kutta ODE Solver with " 
              << n_rk_stages << " stage(s)..." << std::endl;
        if (n_rk_stages == 1){
            return std::make_shared<LowStorageRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,1, MeshType>>(dg_input,ls_rk_tableau,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 2){
            return std::make_shared<LowStorageRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,2, MeshType>>(dg_input,ls_rk_tableau,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 3){
            return std::make_shared<LowStorageRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,3, MeshType>>(dg_input,ls_rk_tableau,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 4){      
            return std::make_shared<LowStorageRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,4, MeshType>>(dg_input,ls_rk_tableau,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 5){
            return std::make_shared<LowStorageRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,5, MeshType>>(dg_input,ls_rk_tableau,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 9){
            return std::make_shared<LowStorageRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,9, MeshType>>(dg_input,ls_rk_tableau,RRK_object);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 10){
            return std::make_shared<LowStorageRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,10, MeshType>>(dg_input,ls_rk_tableau,RRK_object);
        }
        else{
            pcout << "Error: invalid number of stages. Aborting..." << std::endl;
            std::abort();
            return nullptr;
        }
    } else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, false);
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType> 
std::shared_ptr<ODESolverBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_RungeKuttaODESolver(std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim, real, MeshType> > dg_input, std::shared_ptr<ProperOrthogonalDecomposition::PODBase<dim>> pod)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);

    std::shared_ptr<RKTableauBase<dim,real,MeshType>> rk_tableau = create_RKTableau(dg_input);
    std::shared_ptr<EmptyRRKBase<dim,real,MeshType>> RRK_object = create_RRKObject(dg_input, rk_tableau);

    const int n_rk_stages = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.n_rk_stages;
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    const ODEEnum ode_solver_type = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.ode_solver_type;
    if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::pod_galerkin_runge_kutta_solver) {
        // Type-cast to the appropriate RKTableau type
        std::shared_ptr<RKTableauButcherBase<dim,real,MeshType>> rk_tableau_butcher = std::dynamic_pointer_cast<RKTableauButcherBase<dim,real,MeshType>>(rk_tableau); 
        // Hard-coded templating of n_rk_stages because it is not known at compile time
        if(dg_input->all_parameters->use_inverse_mass_on_the_fly){
            pcout   << "Not Implemented: use_inverse_mass_on_the_fly=true && ode_solver_type=pod_galerkin_rk_solver"
                    << '\n' 
                    << "Please set use_inverse_mass_on_the_fly=false and try again"
                    << std::endl;
            std::abort();
        }
        pcout << "Creating Galerkin Runge Kutta ODE Solver with " 
              << n_rk_stages << " stage(s)..." << std::endl;
        if (n_rk_stages == 1){
            return std::make_shared<PODGalerkinRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,1,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object,pod);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 2){
            return std::make_shared<PODGalerkinRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,2,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object,pod);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 3){
            return std::make_shared<PODGalerkinRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,3,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object,pod);
        }
        else if (n_rk_stages == 4){
            return std::make_shared<PODGalerkinRungeKuttaODESolver<dim,real,4,MeshType>>(dg_input,rk_tableau_butcher,RRK_object,pod);
        }
        else{
            pcout << "Error: invalid number of stages. Aborting..." << std::endl;
            std::abort();
            return nullptr;
        }
    }
    else {
        display_error_ode_solver_factory(ode_solver_type, false);
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<RKTableauBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_RKTableau(std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    using RKMethodEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::RKMethodEnum;
    const RKMethodEnum rk_method = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.runge_kutta_method;

    const int n_rk_stages = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.n_rk_stages;

    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::ssprk3_ex)   return std::make_shared<SSPRK3Explicit<dim, real, MeshType>> (n_rk_stages, "3rd order SSP (explicit)");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::rk4_ex)      return std::make_shared<RK4Explicit<dim, real, MeshType>>    (n_rk_stages, "4th order classical RK (explicit)");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::heun2_ex)      return std::make_shared<HeunExplicit<dim, real, MeshType>>    (n_rk_stages, "2nd order Heun's method (explicit)");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::euler_ex) {
        using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
        ODEEnum ode_solver_type = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.ode_solver_type;
        if (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::rrk_explicit_solver) {
            //forward Euler is invalid for RRK: sum(b_i*a_ij) = 0 (see Lemma 2.1 in Ketcheson 2019)
            pcout << "Error: RRK is not valid for Forward Euler. Aborting..." << std::endl;
            std::abort();
            return nullptr;
        } else return std::make_shared<EulerExplicit<dim, real, MeshType>>  (n_rk_stages, "Forward Euler (explicit)");
    }
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::euler_im)    return std::make_shared<EulerImplicit<dim, real, MeshType>>  (n_rk_stages, "Implicit Euler (implicit)");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::dirk_2_im)   return std::make_shared<DIRK2Implicit<dim, real, MeshType>>  (n_rk_stages, "2nd order diagonally-implicit (implicit)");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::dirk_3_im)   return std::make_shared<DIRK3Implicit<dim, real, MeshType>>  (n_rk_stages, "3nd order diagonally-implicit (implicit)");

    //Low storage methods
    const int num_delta = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.num_delta;
    
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::RK3_2_5F_3SStarPlus)         return std::make_shared<RK3_2_5F_3SStarPlus<dim, real, MeshType>> (n_rk_stages, num_delta, "RK3_2_5F_3SStarPlus");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::RK4_3_5_3SStar)              return std::make_shared<RK4_3_5_3SStar<dim, real, MeshType>>    (n_rk_stages, num_delta, "RK4_3_5_3SStar");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::RK4_3_9F_3SStarPlus)         return std::make_shared<RK4_3_9F_3SStarPlus<dim, real, MeshType>>    (n_rk_stages, num_delta, "RK4_3_9F_3SStarPlus");
    if (rk_method == RKMethodEnum::RK5_4_10F_3SStarPlus)        return std::make_shared<RK5_4_10F_3SStarPlus<dim, real, MeshType>>    (n_rk_stages, num_delta, "RK5_4_10F_3SStarPlus");
    else {
        pcout << "Error: invalid RK method. Aborting..." << std::endl;
        std::abort();
        return nullptr;
    }
}

template <int dim, typename real, typename MeshType>
std::shared_ptr<EmptyRRKBase<dim,real,MeshType>> ODESolverFactory<dim,real,MeshType>::create_RRKObject( std::shared_ptr< DGBase<dim,real,MeshType> > dg_input,
       std::shared_ptr<RKTableauBase<dim,real,MeshType>> rk_tableau)
{
    dealii::ConditionalOStream pcout(std::cout, dealii::Utilities::MPI::this_mpi_process(MPI_COMM_WORLD)==0);
    using ODEEnum = Parameters::ODESolverParam::ODESolverEnum;
    const ODEEnum ode_solver_type = dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.ode_solver_type;
    // Type-cast to the appropriate RKTableau type
    std::shared_ptr<RKTableauButcherBase<dim,real,MeshType>> rk_tableau_butcher = std::dynamic_pointer_cast<RKTableauButcherBase<dim,real,MeshType>>(rk_tableau); 

    if ( (ode_solver_type == ODEEnum::runge_kutta_solver && dg_input->all_parameters->flow_solver_param.do_calculate_numerical_entropy)
            || ( !dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.use_relaxation_runge_kutta && dg_input->all_parameters->flow_solver_param.do_calculate_numerical_entropy )  ) {
            return std::make_shared<RKNumEntropy<dim,real,MeshType>>(rk_tableau_butcher);
    }
    else if (dg_input->all_parameters->ode_solver_param.use_relaxation_runge_kutta){

        using PDEEnum = Parameters::AllParameters::PartialDifferentialEquation;
        const PDEEnum pde_type = dg_input->all_parameters->pde_type;
        using NumFluxEnum = Parameters::AllParameters::TwoPointNumericalFlux;
        const NumFluxEnum two_point_num_flux_type = dg_input->all_parameters->two_point_num_flux_type;
        
        enum NumEntropyEnum {energy, nonlinear};
        NumEntropyEnum numerical_entropy_type;
        std::string rrk_type_string;
        if (pde_type == PDEEnum::burgers_inviscid){
            numerical_entropy_type = NumEntropyEnum::energy;
            rrk_type_string = "Algebraic";
        } else if ((pde_type == PDEEnum::euler || pde_type == PDEEnum::navier_stokes)
                    && (two_point_num_flux_type != NumFluxEnum::KG)){
            numerical_entropy_type = NumEntropyEnum::nonlinear;
            rrk_type_string = "Root-finding";
        } else{
            pcout << "PDE type has no assigned numerical entropy variable. Aborting..." << std::endl;
            std::abort();
        }

        pcout << "Adding " << rrk_type_string << " Relaxation Runge Kutta to the ODE solver..." << std::endl;
        if (numerical_entropy_type==NumEntropyEnum::energy)
            return std::make_shared<AlgebraicRRKODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(rk_tableau_butcher);
        else if (numerical_entropy_type==NumEntropyEnum::nonlinear)
            return std::make_shared<RootFindingRRKODESolver<dim,real,MeshType>>(rk_tableau_butcher);
        else return nullptr; // no need for message as numerical_entropy_type has already been checked
    } else {
        return std::make_shared<EmptyRRKBase<dim,real,MeshType>> (rk_tableau_butcher);
    }
}

template class ODESolverFactory<PHILIP_DIM, double, dealii::Triangulation<PHILIP_DIM>>;
template class ODESolverFactory<PHILIP_DIM, double, dealii::parallel::shared::Triangulation<PHILIP_DIM>>;
#if PHILIP_DIM != 1
    template class ODESolverFactory<PHILIP_DIM, double, dealii::parallel::distributed::Triangulation<PHILIP_DIM>>;
#endif

} // ODE namespace
} // PHiLiP namespace